Home About Search Properties Resources Blog Contact {{agentDetails.offc_phone}}

{{status_msg}}

Home Prices Are Softening. What Buyers Can Negotiate Now

Posted:

November 17th

  • Share on Facebook

For over three years, the average home in America consistently sold for more than its previous year's value each month. That trend has recently come to a halt. According to data from October, the median home sale price has dipped slightly below the level seen last year, marking the first yearly decline since the spring of 2023. Concurrently, the inventory of homes available has surged to its highest point since early 2020, pending sales have fallen to their lowest levels outside the early pandemic, and approximately one in five listings has experienced a price reduction.

Compounding the situation, borrowing costs have risen again. The average 30-year fixed mortgage rate has surged back into the mid-7% range over the last week, following a brief period of improvement. Therefore, while buyers are gaining some negotiating power, many households still find their monthly payments challenging to manage.

This unique situation presents a distinctive opportunity. Sellers are contending with fewer offers and extended time on the market, leading them to view the list price and sale terms as more of a starting point rather than a conclusive figure. If you're on the hunt for a home this winter, here are potential negotiation points to discuss with your agent and lender.

The Implications of a Small Price Reduction

A national price drop of less than half a percent isn't a crash, and it doesn't indicate a universal decline in prices. High-end coastal markets with limited inventory continue to see price increases, while some significant metro areas in the South and West have recorded price drops of several percent compared to last year. Understanding the conditions of your local market is far more critical than national trends.

The national figures suggest a shift in power dynamics. When homes linger on the market and numerous listings compete for a smaller pool of buyers, sellers tend to become more amenable to negotiations. This openness can reflect in the sale price, but it often manifests more prominently in the terms of the deal.

Looking Beyond the Sale Price

Buyers frequently concentrate exclusively on the purchase price, but in a high-interest environment, the monthly payment and cash needed at closing can have an even greater impact. A few thousand dollars shaved off the purchase price only minimally affects the loan amount. In contrast, allocating that same money differently can provide more significant relief to your budget. Common negotiating points in a slower market include:

  • A lower purchase price than what is listed
  • A seller credit to assist with closing costs
  • Repairs to be completed prior to closing, or a credit if repairs are needed
  • An offer from the seller to pay points to reduce your mortgage rate
  • A closing timeline that accommodates your schedule
  • Inclusions like appliances or window treatments with the home

Your real estate agent is familiar with how sellers are responding in your area and can help you prioritize which aspects to negotiate in your offer. It's not about requesting everything, but rather targeting items that will have the most significant impact on your situation.

Closing Cost Credits Can Alleviate Financial Strain

Closing costs generally amount to a few percent of the loan total, in addition to your down payment. For many first-time homebuyers, gathering enough cash for these costs can be one of the most challenging parts of purchasing. A seller credit can cover some of these fees directly, allowing you to bring less cash to closing.

However, there are limitations. Loan programs often cap how much a seller can contribute, typically ranging from 3% to 9% of the sales price, depending on the specific loan type and the down payment size. Additionally, credits usually cannot exceed your actual closing expenses. It's advisable to consult your lender early on to understand what your particular loan permits so that any requests align with the applicable regulations.

Understanding Rate Buydowns

With rates now back above 7%, one of the most beneficial offers a seller can make may involve assisting with your interest rate. There are two primary approaches.

A permanent buydown utilizes discount points paid during closing to decrease your rate for the duration of the loan. Each point typically costs 1% of the loan total, and the specific rate reduction can vary based on the lender and current market conditions. If you plan to maintain the loan for several years, a permanent buydown could prove advantageous.

A temporary buydown lowers your monthly payments initially, for either the first year or two. In a standard scenario, the rate may be reduced by two percentage points in the first year and one point in the second, before reverting to the full rate. For instance, on a $350,000 30-year loan at a rate of about 7.34%, principal and interest payments would total approximately $2,409 per month. With a temporary buydown, the first-year payment would be about $1,952, and the second-year payment would rise to approximately $2,176, before settling at the full amount in year three. Organizing this financial arrangement costs roughly $8,000 in the example, which the seller might consider covering instead of lowering the price equivalently.

Keep in mind that a temporary buydown is not a long-term solution. You need to be ready for the total payment once the discount period concludes, and lenders typically qualify you based on the full rate. If interest rates decrease in the future, refinancing could be a viable option, but there are no guarantees regarding timing or occurrence.

Importance of a Home Inspection

In a frantic market, many buyers opted to waive inspections or limited their requests to broaden their chances in bidding wars. However, in a slower market, there's less compulsion to forfeit these protections. A comprehensive home inspection can provide insight into the state of the roof, HVAC systems, plumbing, electrical work, and foundation before making a commitment.

If the inspection uncovers issues, your agent can guide you in deciding whether to request repairs, negotiate a price adjustment, or seek a credit. Often, credits are simpler to manage than repairs conducted by the seller, as they allow you to choose who will address the work and how it will be completed. Ultimately, the best route depends on the specific issue and your loan's stipulations.

Preparation is Key for Financing

Having negotiating power means little if your financing is uncertain. A seller evaluating two offers will typically prefer the buyer who appears most likely to close the deal. Before beginning your home hunt, secure a full preapproval rather than a simple prequalification, identify your maximum comfortable monthly payment rather than just the maximum loan you can obtain, and obtain loan estimates from multiple lenders. Inquire how each lender would address seller credits or buydowns to avoid any surprises along the way.

Essential Questions for Your Agent

  • What is the average time homes sit on the market in this area, and how frequently do prices get lowered?
  • Would a price decrease, a closing cost credit, or a rate buydown be most advantageous for my budget?
  • How do the condition and history of this particular property influence my negotiation options?
  • Which contingencies should I include in my offer to ensure my protection?

Final Thoughts

A less competitive market does not equate to lower buying costs, especially with rising mortgage rates. Nevertheless, it grants prepared buyers more flexibility to negotiate terms that align with their financial situation. By ensuring solid financing, maintaining clarity on your priorities, and utilizing your agent's and lender's insights, you might achieve more favorable terms than buyers had anticipated just a year or two prior.

Rewritten using AI